When Will a Genetic Algorithm Outperform Hill Climbing?
نویسندگان
چکیده
In this paper we review some previously published experimental results in which a simple hillclimbing algorithm-Random Mutation Hill-Climbing (RMHC)-significantly outperforms a genetic algorithm on a simple "Royal Road" function. vVe present an analysis of RMHC followed by an analysis of an "idealized" genetic algorithm (IGA) that is in turn significantly faster than RMHC. We isolate the features of the IGA that allow for this speedup, and discuss how these features can be incorporated into a real GA and a fitness landscape, making the GA better approximate the IGA. We use these features to design a modified version of the previously published experiments, and give new experimental results comparing the GA and RMHC.
منابع مشابه
Improving the efficiency of the distributed stochastic algorithm
The Distributed Stochastic Algorithm (DSA) is a distributed hill-climbing technique for solving large Distributed Constraint Optimization Problems (DCOPs) such as distributed scheduling, resource allocation, and distributed route planning. The best known version of DSA, DSA-B, works by having agents change their assignments with probability p when making that change will improve their solution ...
متن کاملComparison of Genetic and Hill Climbing Algorithms to Improve an Artificial Neural Networks Model for Water Consumption Prediction
No unique method has been so far specified for determining the number of neurons in hidden layers of Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP) neural networks used for prediction. The present research is intended to optimize the number of neurons using two meta-heuristic procedures namely genetic and hill climbing algorithms. The data used in the present research for prediction are consumption data of water...
متن کاملFast retrieval of similar configurations
Configuration similarity is a special form of content-based image retrieval that considers relative object locations. It can be used as a standalone method, or to complement retrieval based on visual or semantic features. The corresponding queries ask for sets of objects that satisfy some spatio-temporal constraints, e.g., “find all triplets of objects ( 1, 2, 3), such that 1 is northeast of 2,...
متن کاملA Proposed Improved Hybrid Hill Climbing Algorithm with the Capability of Local Search for Solving the Nonlinear Economic Load Dispatch Problem
This paper introduces a new hybrid hill-climbing algorithm (HHC) for solving the Economic Dispatch (ED) problem. This algorithm solves the ED problems with a systematic search structure with a global search. It improves the results obtained from an evolutionary algorithm with local search and converges to the best possible solution that grabs the accuracy of the problem. The most important goal...
متن کاملA general-purpose hill-climbing method for order independent minimum grouping problems: A case study in graph colouring and bin packing
A class of problems referred to as Order Independent Minimum Grouping Problems is examined and an intuitive hill-climbing method for solving such problems is proposed. Example applications of this generic method are made to two well-known problems belonging to this class: graph colouring and bin packing. Using a wide variety of different problem instance-types, these algorithms are compared to ...
متن کامل